TestRail alternative
A TestRail alternative that tells you when you can ship
TestPlum keeps the test repository and runs you know from TestRail. It adds one answer on top: whether the release is ready, with the reasons in plain words.
TestPlum is a TestRail alternative for teams that want manual and automated results in one place and a clear Ready or Not ready verdict for each release. It imports TestRail XML or CSV exports with sections, steps and custom fields, and each test keeps its C-number. It is free for up to 3 testers, and viewers are free on every plan.
Who should switch, and who should stay
TestRail is a long-standing test case manager, and many teams run it well. Switching is worth it when the thing you need most is not a better place to store tests, but a better answer about the release.
- Switch if your release meeting is a judgement call, if automated results live somewhere other than your manual runs, or if you pay for seats for people who only need to look.
- Switch if your CI already writes JUnit XML, CTRF or Allure reports and you want them counted toward the release without extra tooling.
- Stay if you need SAML single sign-on today. TestPlum supports OpenID Connect sign-on; SAML is not built yet.
- Stay if you rely on TestRail's own reports, plans and milestones in daily work. TestPlum has releases, cycles and runs instead, and plans and milestones are not imported.
- Stay, or wait, if you need to run it on your own servers on a small plan. Self-hosting is part of TestPlum's Enterprise agreement only.
TestPlum and TestRail side by side
What each tool offers, as of the date on this page. For TestRail we list only what its own pricing page says; where it doesn't say, check their docs.
| Capability | TestPlum | TestRail |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Per tester; viewers free on every plan | Per user; three paid plans on the pricing page |
| Free option | Free plan: up to 3 testers, 1 project, no time limit | 30-day free trial, no card needed |
| Hosting | Cloud; self-hosting on Enterprise | Cloud; on-premise on Professional and Enterprise (10+ seats, 12-month minimum) |
| Import from TestRail | XML or CSV export, IDs kept, past run results too | Not applicable |
| CI results | JUnit XML, CTRF and Allure by one curl step | CI/CD integrations listed, such as Jenkins, GitHub Actions and Azure DevOps |
| Release verdict | Ready or Not ready from agreed checks, with plain reasons | See their docs |
| Pass weighed by evidence | Trusted pass rate: retries, flaky passes and passes with no assertions count partly | See their docs |
| Failure grouping and sorting | Grouped by cause; sorted as bug, broken test, environment or flaky | See their docs |
| Flaky-test quarantine | Yes, with reason, owner and expiry | See their docs |
| Jira | Send bugs, two-way status sync, import stories as requirements | Jira integration listed on the pricing page |
| Single sign-on | OpenID Connect on Business | SSO on Enterprise |
| REST API | Yes, with API keys and signed webhooks | Yes; request limits differ by plan |
What the TestRail importer brings over
Export a suite from TestRail as XML or CSV and upload it under Tests, Import, TestRail. You see how many tests are new, updated, unchanged or skipped before anything is saved, and nothing is written unless every test is valid.
- Sections and subsections become folders, in the same order, including empty ones.
- Steps, expected results, preconditions, priority (also the 1–5 scale), type, estimate and references come across.
- Custom fields fill matching fields in TestPlum, or an administrator can have them created for you.
- Each test keeps its case ID (C123), so importing a newer export updates the same tests instead of adding copies. You can keep using TestRail while you switch.
- Attachments and images pasted into text can be copied over with a TestRail API key you give once. The key is used for that copy only and never stored.
- Past results come too: a test run's CSV export becomes a signed-off run dated as it happened, with tester, comment and defects. It adds history but never changes the release verdict.
Send CI results with one curl step
Many teams keep automated results in their CI and manual results in TestRail. In TestPlum both land in the same runs, so the verdict covers everything that was tested.
TestPlum takes JUnit XML, CTRF JSON and Allure results at one address and works out the format from the content. CTRF covers reporters for Cypress, Jest, Vitest, pytest and more. Retries in CTRF and Allure are kept as separate attempts, so a test that passed only on its second try shows up as flaky instead of green.
Open Runs, Connect CI, pick your test tool (Playwright, Jest, Vitest, pytest or any JUnit XML) and your CI (GitHub Actions, GitLab CI or another), and create a CI key. The key is shown once and can only send results and read the answer for that project. The page waits for your first run and shows it as soon as it lands. Nothing to install: the step is plain curl.
curl -f -sS -X POST \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $TESTPLUM_CI_KEY" \
-H "Content-Type: application/xml" \
--data-binary @junit.xml -o /dev/null \
"https://app.testplum.com/api/v1/projects/<project-id>/automation/report?release=%40next&run_name=CI%20%23<build>"A release verdict instead of a meeting
Open a project and the first thing you see is whether the release due next can ship. Read how it works on the release verdict page.
- Ready or Not ready, from checks you agree in advance: runs in scope, completion, pass rate, trusted pass rate, critical tests failing or blocked, open critical bugs and requirements verified.
- Each failing check reads as one plain sentence, such as “Only 50% of tests pass. Needs 95%.”, with one button to the page that fixes it.
- A pass counts by what it proves. A pass on retry, from a flaky test or with no assertions counts only partly, so a green suite of weak tests cannot make a release look ready.
- Your build can print the answer in its log, or stop when the release is Not ready.
Failures sorted by cause
A red run tells you something broke. TestPlum tells you what kind of problem it is. More on failure triage.
- Failures that share a cause are grouped, so ten tests failing for one reason are one problem.
- Each group is sorted as a product bug, a broken test, an environment problem or a flaky test, by visible rules, with the reasons and a confidence.
- File one bug per cause and send it to Jira or GitHub. Its status stays in sync both ways.
- Flaky tests can be quarantined with a reason, an owner and an expiry. They stay out of the verdict counts until a fix is confirmed, except that a quarantined critical test keeps the verdict at Not ready.
How the pricing models differ
TestPlum is priced per tester. Free covers up to 3 testers, unlimited viewers and one project with no time limit. Team is $19 and Business $35 per tester per month, billed yearly. Viewers, such as developers, product managers and managers, are free on every plan, and people in connected tools such as Jira or GitHub are never counted. See pricing.
TestRail prices per user. Its pricing page lists Essentials at $22 per user per month billed annually, for up to 5 users and cloud only, and Enterprise at $78 per user per month billed annually, with Professional in between. Every plan has a 30-day free trial.
The practical difference is who you pay for. If ten testers and forty developers and managers all need to see results, TestPlum charges for the ten. Paid TestPlum plans are set up with the TestPlum team for now, as checkout in the app is not available yet.
How to move from TestRail
- Create a free workspace. Sign up and create a project. Free covers up to 3 testers with no time limit.
- Export one suite. In TestRail, open the suite, choose Export, then XML. XML keeps every section, step and field.
- Check and import. Upload it under Tests, Import, TestRail. Fix anything the check lists, then import. The TestRail migration guide shows where each field lands.
- Bring past results. Export recent runs as CSV with at least the Case ID and Status columns and import them as past results.
- Connect CI. Add the curl step from Runs, Connect CI so automated results land in the same release.
- Run both for a while. Import a newer export whenever TestRail changes. Only changed tests are updated.
Frequently asked questions
Can I import TestRail test cases?
Yes. Upload a TestRail XML or CSV export under Tests, Import, TestRail. Sections, steps, priorities and custom fields come across, and each test keeps its C-number so a newer export updates it.
Is there a free TestRail alternative?
TestPlum has a free plan for up to 3 testers with unlimited viewers, one project and unlimited automation results, with no time limit. The TestRail import is included.
Can I import past TestRail runs and results?
Yes. Export a run as CSV with at least the Case ID and Status columns. Each run becomes a signed-off run dated as it happened, with tester, comment and defects, and importing it again changes nothing.
Does TestPlum work with Jira?
Yes. Send a bug to a connected Jira project and its status stays in sync both ways. Jira stories can be imported by JQL as requirements, with a comment on each listing the tests that cover it.
Can we keep using TestRail while we switch?
Yes. Tests are matched by their TestRail ID, so you can import a newer export as often as you like and only changed tests are updated.
Do I need to install anything in CI?
No. One curl step sends a JUnit XML, CTRF or Allure report. Runs, Connect CI writes the step for your test tool and CI.
Sources
- TestRail pricing, checked November 19, 2026
TestRail is a trademark of its owner. TestPlum is not affiliated with or endorsed by it; the name is used only to compare and to describe what TestPlum can import.